TrupanionCA
Trupanion bilateral cruciate denial overturned
A Labrador's right CCL tear was denied as a bilateral pre-existing condition after a left CCL repair two years earlier.
What worked: Orthopedic specialist letter distinguishing the two events as independent traumatic injuries, supported by intra-operative photos showing acute fiber rupture (not chronic degeneration).
Labrador Retriever · dogIllustrative case
EmbraceTX
Embrace allergy denial overturned
An allergy flare-up was denied as pre-existing despite a 12-month symptom-free window before the policy started.
What worked: Vet's signed timeline confirming a clear symptom-free interval and an allergen exposure documented after coverage began.
French Bulldog · dogIllustrative case
Healthy PawsNY
Healthy Paws hip dysplasia 'congenital' denial overturned
Hip surgery denied as a congenital exclusion despite no prior symptoms or imaging.
What worked: Original orthopedic radiographs read by a board-certified radiologist showing acute degenerative change, not congenital dysplasia.
German Shepherd · dogIllustrative case
ASPCAFL
ASPCA dental extraction denial overturned
Dental extraction denied as a routine dental procedure under the wellness exclusion.
What worked: Histopathology report distinguishing tooth-resorption disease from preventive cleaning, supported by AVMA dental-disease guidance.
Domestic Shorthair · catIllustrative case
LemonadeWA
Lemonade UTI waiting-period denial overturned
Urinary tract infection denied as occurring within the illness waiting period.
What worked: Vet visit timestamp clearly after the waiting period ended; insurer had miscounted by treating the policy purchase date as day-zero of waiting.
Maine Coon · catIllustrative case
MetLifeGA
MetLife mast-cell tumor denial overturned
Mast cell tumor surgery denied as a pre-existing skin condition based on a prior 'lump' note.
What worked: Biopsy report showing the prior lump was a benign lipoma at a different anatomic site, distinguishing it from the cancerous tumor.
Boxer · dogIllustrative case
Pets BestOH
Pets Best ACL bilateral denial overturned
Second ACL repair denied as bilateral despite a clean medical history for the second leg.
What worked: Lameness exam notes showing the contralateral leg was symptom-free for 18 months between events, plus owner's clear timeline of acute trauma.
Golden Retriever · dogIllustrative case
SpotIL
Spot bilateral ear infection denial overturned
Bilateral ear infections in a breed-prone dog denied as bilateral exclusion.
What worked: Argument that infectious otitis is event-based, not anatomic — supported by separate culture results for each ear.
Cocker Spaniel · dogIllustrative case
FigoCO
Figo emergency foreign-body surgery denial overturned
Foreign body surgery denied due to prior gastroenteritis notes interpreted as 'GI issues.'
What worked: Imaging confirming acute foreign body, distinguishing the surgery from any pre-existing GI complaint.
Beagle · dogIllustrative case
NationwideMA
Nationwide lymphoma staging denial overturned
Staging workup for lymphoma denied as 'diagnostic'.
What worked: Treatment-planning note from oncologist showing the staging directly determined chemotherapy protocol — qualifying as treatment, not screening.
Golden Retriever · dogIllustrative case
TrupanionOR
Trupanion IBD chronic-care denial overturned
Maintenance therapy for IBD denied as exceeding chronic-condition annual limit.
What worked: Policy language re-reading: per-condition annual limit applied, not per-claim — recovered the remaining balance.
Siamese · catIllustrative case
EmbraceAZ
Embrace luxating patella 'congenital' denial overturned
Grade III patella surgery denied as a congenital condition for a small-breed dog.
What worked: Vet exam history showing no patellar laxity at puppy exams, supporting acquired-injury argument.
Pomeranian · dogIllustrative case
Healthy PawsNJ
Healthy Paws pancreatitis recurrence denial overturned
Acute pancreatitis denied as recurrence of an episode that occurred 3 years prior.
What worked: Demonstrated >18-month symptom-free interval, which the policy defined as a 'cured' condition no longer pre-existing.
Miniature Schnauzer · dogIllustrative case
ASPCANC
ASPCA insulin coverage denial overturned
Long-term insulin denied as maintenance after initial 90 days.
What worked: Treatment-protocol letter confirming ongoing therapeutic (not maintenance) need, supported by glucose curve documentation.
Domestic Longhair · catIllustrative case
LemonadeAZ
Lemonade rattlesnake-bite ER denial overturned
Emergency ER denied for using a non-network hospital.
What worked: Policy emergency-exception clause invoked: nearest in-network ER was >60 minutes away during a venomous bite.
Labrador Retriever · dogIllustrative case
MetLifePA
MetLife hyperthyroidism denial overturned
Hyperthyroidism denied based on a single elevated T4 from before coverage.
What worked: Vet's signed letter that the prior T4 elevation was within laboratory variation, with no diagnosis or treatment having occurred pre-policy.
Domestic Shorthair · catIllustrative case
Pets BestTX
Pets Best cherry-eye bilateral denial overturned
Second-eye cherry-eye repair denied as bilateral.
What worked: Independent ophthalmology exam supported separate acute prolapse events months apart with no chronic prolapse on prior exam.
Bulldog · dogIllustrative case
SpotMN
Spot DKA hospitalization denial overturned
DKA hospitalization denied based on a single prior glucose reading.
What worked: Demonstrated DKA is a discrete, acute event — different ICD code than diabetes mellitus — and prior glucose did not constitute diagnosis.
Maine Coon · catIllustrative case
FigoVA
Figo TPLO revision denial overturned
Revision TPLO denied as pre-existing because the first TPLO occurred years earlier.
What worked: Surgeon's note that the revision was for implant failure (a discrete surgical complication), not progression of CCL disease.
Rottweiler · dogIllustrative case
NationwideMI
Nationwide megaesophagus 'congenital' denial overturned
Megaesophagus denied as congenital in an adult-onset case.
What worked: Imaging timeline and adult-onset acquired diagnosis distinguished it from congenital megaesophagus, supported by internal medicine specialist.
Great Dane · dogIllustrative case
TrupanionFL
Trupanion glaucoma second-eye denial overturned
Second-eye glaucoma denied bilateral despite >2 years between events.
What worked: Tonometry records showed normal IOP in the second eye for 26 months — supported acquired (not bilateral congenital) classification.
Cocker Spaniel · dogIllustrative case
EmbraceNV
Embrace Cushing's disease denial overturned
Cushing's diagnosis denied as pre-existing due to prior elevated ALP.
What worked: Endocrinology letter confirming elevated ALP alone is not diagnostic and the workup (LDDS) occurred post-policy.
Dachshund · dogIllustrative case
Healthy PawsCT
Healthy Paws vestibular-disease denial overturned
Vestibular workup denied as diagnostic screening.
What worked: Documentation that imaging was ordered to direct treatment after acute presentation, not as screening.
Beagle · dogIllustrative case
LemonadeOR
Lemonade pyometra emergency denial overturned
Emergency pyometra surgery denied because the pet was unspayed at enrollment.
What worked: Argument that being intact is a status, not a condition or diagnosis — pyometra was an acute illness with onset post-policy.
Labrador Retriever · dogIllustrative case
MetLifeTN
MetLife xylitol toxicity denial overturned
Xylitol emergency denied for out-of-network ER.
What worked: Invoked toxicity-emergency clause; closest network ER was 90 minutes away — life-threat exception applied.
Yorkie · dogIllustrative case
Build your own appeal in 10 minutes
We'll customize the letter to your insurer, your pet, and the exact reason cited in your denial.
Start my appeal →